Are traditional interviews becoming irrelevant?


Interviews are by far the most common method used to assess an individual’s suitability for a job. And yet, when the pros and cons of this approach are compared with the alternatives, it is hard to think of the traditional face-to-face, question-based interview as anything other than an old-fashioned exercise which could potentially be a waste of candidates’ time and a company’s money.

Traditional interviews can be a frustrating experience for both parties. Often unstructured and littered with generic questions, candidates find themselves resorting to practiced answers and the interviewer is left to make an important decision without the required level of information. Not to mention this format also allows for discrimination or unconscious bias to play a role in the hiring decision. Many recruiters and hiring managers appear to have a never-ending love affair with traditional interviews, but do they know there are alternatives out there?

“I think the reason a lot of hiring managers and recruiters go with traditional methods is largely down to, like you said, not knowing any other way. Or, even if they are aware of other methods, not having the required level of training or fully understanding the benefits can make someone less confident in exploring them”, explains Amber Dique-Bellette.

“Most recruiters and many hiring managers have been taught how to conduct a traditional interview and this means they have confidence they can accurately assess a candidates suitability for a position. If you’ve never used a non-traditional method to recruit, it can certainly feel like a risk using one you don’t know! Given how important successful recruitment is to a business, it’s understandable that many hiring managers like to use a process that they know well.”

As Recruitment Team Leader for Employment Office – one of SCOUT’s valued partners – Amber is well acquainted with a variety of interview and assessment methods, carrying these out on behalf of a number of clients. And, it’s fair to say, some are certainly more interesting than others.

“We do a lot of assessment centres for our clients, which have included some very different things! There have been a lot of customer service role plays. We even had one client get candidates to leave a voicemail in a role play environment because they wanted to hear what they sounded like when doing so. We’ve got candidates to do role-specific tasks, like writing a performance review or some kind of reporting. We’ve had them show us how they’d handle an aggressive client or a complaint. And we even had a prospect once that assessed people’s hand writing as part of the hiring process!”

Alex Hood, SCOUT Training and Implementation Specialist, has worked with many clients in implementing the system to match their recruitment process. As a result he has seen lots of different recruitment strategies and approaches.

“Hundreds of Australian companies use SCOUT to manage their recruitment and interview processes, and the variety of interview types that are conducted within the system is really interesting. I’ve seen clients experiment with everything from 10 minute phone interviews to Skype interviews to video interviews to group assessments,” notes Alex. “We’re seeing a rise in the “2 minute video resume” which gives the Hiring Manager a good feel for the candidate before deciding whether or not to interview them at all.”

With so many alternative approaches available, we would love to hear your thoughts on what you think interviewing will look like in the future. Please feel free to leave a comment below and join the discussion!

18 replies
  1. Lutherpiefs
    Lutherpiefs says:


  2. AnthonyWak
    AnthonyWak says:

    Any micro-chip contains a considerable affect on if perhaps you all reap the rewards and / or non-winner in texas hold’em video playback. The fashion you perform the fretting hand is additionally needed, nonetheless, stands out as the micro-chip commonly known as this RNG (Arbitrary Handful Grinding machine) that provides the danger for your personal person to regulate all the sensible game or just botch time. To refer to, think about the electronic poker via internet brewing system being Notebook computer. It`d be advisable to take care of as that’s what it may be. Consider system you use both at home and your office. It`s set to employ exact functions. Most of the gardening exists, however it wants orders so as to employment. Hence you install applications. Within understood variables, laptop will make everything you management. Critiques one operation, permit it to manage, after which they get going one other whilst not having disturbing the operation of a major only one. If you ever publications way up copy, the evolution pushes the suitable specifics in the printing and publishing machine, and be able to carries on perform the job. Conclusion . does not need to choose these machine is conducted, very much the same way of thinking along with the video poker action. Laptop computer is definitely designed to come up with virtually every manageable internet poker fingers, persistently. Individuals have an understanding of quickly in addition to times. Every day are operating in nanoseconds. In your space of time you will need to make sure you ask for a the company, computers regularly have passed over all doable line-up hundred or so occasions.

  3. Takishacag
    Takishacag says:

    Шумоизоляция организована со всех сторон. Горизонтальная лежит между этажами. На монолитную плиту — перекрытие — укладывается шумоизоляционный материал. А сверху — стяжка пола.
    , подробнее на

  4. Anonymous
    Anonymous says:

    Great blog you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any message boards that cover the same topics discussed here? I’d really love to be a part of community where I can get feedback from other experienced people that share the same interest. If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.